Is There a Proper Way to Use Physical Punishment? What Parents Should Know

A therapist's 3 rules for parents: check your anger first, explain the mistake, and keep discipline private. Plus clear limits and other tools that work.

PARENTING

Mr. P

11/17/20263 min read

Father and son are enjoying a fishing trip
Father and son are enjoying a fishing trip
Can parents still use physical punishment?

It's one of the questions I hear most from parents, usually asked quietly, almost like a confession: "Is it still okay to spank?"

The short answer is yes. In most of the United States, including California, reasonable physical discipline by a parent is still legal. But there's a lot more to it than "yes." How, when, and why it happens makes all the difference between discipline that teaches and punishment that just hurts.

If you choose to use physical discipline in your home, here are three rules I want every parent to follow first.

Rule 1: Check your own anger first

This is the most important rule. Physical punishment should never happen when you are angry.

When we're angry, our judgment narrows. It's easy to go harder than we meant to, and the punishment becomes about releasing our frustration rather than teaching our child. Children also learn by watching us. If they see a parent hit when upset, the lesson they learn is "when I'm mad, I hit."

Before you respond, try this quick check-in:

  1. Pause. Stop what you're doing and take three slow breaths.

  2. Rate your anger from 1 to 10. Be honest with yourself.

  3. If you're above a 3, step away. Tell your child, "I'm too upset to deal with this right now. We'll talk in a few minutes." Then come back when you're calm.

Taking a break isn't letting your child off the hook. It's showing them what self-control looks like.

Rule 2: Explain the mistake and the reason

A consequence without an explanation teaches fear, not the lesson.

Before any discipline, get down to your child's eye level and tell them calmly:

  • What they did: "You hit your sister and took her toy."

  • Why it's not okay: "Hitting hurts people, and that toy was hers."

  • What happens now: "So there's a consequence."

  • What to do next time: "Next time you want something, ask, or come get me."

Keep it short and simple for younger children. The goal is for your child to connect the behavior with the consequence, and to know what to do differently.

Rule 3: Keep it private

Discipline should never happen in front of siblings, relatives, friends, or anyone else.

When a child is punished in front of others, the lesson gets lost under feelings of guilt and shame. Instead of thinking about what they did, they're thinking about who saw it. Shame tells a child "I am bad," when what we want them to learn is "I made a bad choice."

Take your child to a quiet, private space, like their bedroom. This protects their dignity and keeps the focus where it belongs: on the behavior.

Know the line between discipline and abuse

There is a clear line, and every parent needs to know where it is. Physical discipline crosses into abuse when it:

  • Uses a belt, paddle, switch, or any object

  • Strikes the face, head, or any area other than the bottom

  • Leaves a mark, bruise, or injury

  • Happens in anger or as a way to vent frustration

  • Is the first or only tool you use

If you notice any of these happening in your home, or you feel like you can't stop once you start, please reach out for help. That's not a failure. It's a sign of a parent who cares.

Physical punishment shouldn't be your only tool

Many experts, including the American Academy of Pediatrics, recommend non-physical discipline, and research shows these tools work at least as well. Whatever you decide about physical discipline, these belong in every parent's toolbox:

  • Time out: A short, calm break away from the fun, about one minute per year of age.

  • Losing a privilege: Less screen time, a favorite toy put away, or missing an activity.

  • Natural consequences: Toys left outside get rained on. Homework not done means talking to the teacher.

  • Catching them being good: Praise the behavior you want to see, and be specific. "You shared your blocks with your brother. That was kind."

For more on how reinforcement and punishment work together, read my earlier post, Navigating Parenting: The Balance of Reinforcement and Punishment.

The bottom line

Discipline is about teaching, not hurting. Whatever tools you use, the most important parts are the ones that happen before and after the consequence: a calm parent, a clear explanation, and a child who still feels safe and loved.

If you're feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or unsure whether your approach is working, you don't have to figure it out alone. Parenting support is one of the most common reasons families come to therapy, and it can make a real difference.

Read more at mrpslifesession.com.

This post is for education and is not a substitute for therapy or professional advice.

Wellness

Empowering mental health and life wellness resources.

Social

mainlinecounseling@gmail.com

© 2024. All rights reserved.